Back to Reviews
Cover of Anne of the Island

Anne of the Island

by L. M. Montgomery

5 out of 5
Historical Fiction
Ages 12+

Anne of the Island by L. M. Montgomery is possibly the most romantic Anne book. It is one of my favorites!! Anne is finally going to Redmond College—alongside several childhood chums Gilbert Blythe, Priscilla Grant, and Charlie Sloane. The emotions she feels are bittersweet, she looks forward to the college years before her and, at the same time, dreads them. She suffers from the terrible illness of homesickness, but soon she is happy and herself again, and with the help of her new friends like Philippa Gordon and old friends like Priscilla Grant and Stella Maynard, she begins to feel at home. The girls don’t enjoy boarding houses and that dislike leads them to a decision to rent a house together. Soon Anne is happily living the college life at a wonderful little house called Patty’s Place. During her years at Redmond, Anne encounters several romantic and unromantic proposals, including one from the dashing Roy Gardner. Anne thinks he may be the man of her dreams, but her heart is not quite as certain as her imagination. As the story unfolds, Anne begins to question whether her dreams of romance match what she truly wants in life. But when a serious event shakes Anne’s world, she is forced to look honestly at her own heart. This book is a wonderful read, and will surely be a well-loved book in the series.

Favorite Character

My Favorite Character: “I really love Rusty, the cat Anne acquires, his name suits him well even if it isn’t very romantic, and well, he just can’t be forgotten, even if he is just the cat.” —Millie J.

Parent Note

Parental Guidance: Romance plays a larger role in this book than in earlier Anne books. Readers will encounter themes of courtship, proposals, and young adult relationships, though all are presented with Montgomery's characteristic charm and propriety.

Under the Oaks logoUnder the Oaks

A cozy place for thoughtful book reviews and creative writing. This site is parent-supported and focused on thoughtful, family-friendly book recommendations.

© 2026 Under the Oaks. All rights reserved.